1 ) 女主角選錯(cuò)了,其他都行。
劇情過(guò)得去,唯一吐槽的是女主,她適合演40歲以上孩子的媽咪,真的不適合演出年輕人。天地男兒里的角色就很適合她。黎耀祥和文頌嫻的表演很到位,點(diǎn)贊。每個(gè)案件絲絲相扣,雖有有些不合邏輯,或者說(shuō)不符合常人的做法,但是總體還是可以的,在tvb的懸疑劇中也算是一個(gè)比較新穎的了,值得推薦給大家看一看。
2 ) tvb推理代表作之一
整部劇集其實(shí)只有一個(gè)案件,正如片名都是圍繞一個(gè)家族兩代人30年都被一個(gè)奸人所害,主要是揭露香港富豪家族的道德淪喪,tvb風(fēng)格結(jié)尾肯定大團(tuán)圓。最后的結(jié)尾歐陽(yáng)偉的真實(shí)身份太震驚有點(diǎn)科幻外,案情推理還是很嚴(yán)謹(jǐn)?shù)模砀缴砗痛髱Z山尋迷驚悚程度不足,畢竟全片不是以驚悚為看點(diǎn),點(diǎn)到為止。主演及黃金配角的演技就不用點(diǎn)評(píng)論了一如既往地好評(píng),反派角色演技出神入化,家庭親情感情線不錯(cuò),男女主角的愛(ài)情線冗長(zhǎng),算得上是tvb的推理代表作之一。
3 ) Greed Mask
Roger Kwok Chun On, Christine Ng Wing Mei, Annie Man Chung Han, Wayne Lai Yiu Cheung, Gilbert Lam Wai Sun, Cheung Wai Yee, Edmund So Chi Wai, Lo Koon Lan, Halina Tam Siu Wan, Lo Hoi Pang
What, when, where and who
I am not sure how to write this review without telling you the storyline, because if I tell you the storyline, you will blaming me for telling you too much... but if I don't tell you anything, this page will be empty. Oh well... here is the big picture of the story: the story is like a big puzzle, which involves the death of Roger's father, and the murder who planned the whole set. There are many little cases, and there are lots of suspects, which link one another, and making the big puzzle more and more clear, until the puzzle finally got solved by Roger, Christine (Roger's girlfriend) and Annie. The relationships in this series are pretty interesting and complicated, but I can't tell you too much, the only things I can tell you is that, Roger and Christine are lovers, Annie has crush on Roger, and so is Halina, but who turned out to be really crazy...
THE FACTORS
- Dislike Factor
Christine Ng
I really like this series because of the storyline and Roger Kwok, but I will really love this series if they use someone else instead of Christine. The major reason is that Christine just can't act in this series, I especially don't like the way she screams... I am just so not use to the way she acts, makes me feel that she is trying too much, but she couldn't do anything.
- Love Factor
Roger Kwok
Roger delivers very amazing performances in this series, especially the crying scenes, felt so touching and memorable. I loved his character as well, who has a very tough background, and the fact that he is supposedly "designed" (a tool) for the murder puzzle. His real identity has a very interesting twist, and makes his relationship with the others changed dramatically.
Annie Man
I love to see her and Roger together a lot more than watching Roger and Christine together. Annie and Roger always together solving puzzles, I just love the way they communicate with each other. Annie's hearing and speaking skills are not as normal as regular persons, she sometimes communicate with Roger with sign language, and Roger always takes care of her and helping her go through many difficulties, which makes Annie has serious crush on Roger...
The storyline
This entire series is just about one case, however, there are many links to the result of the case, which makes the entire storyline so interesting, and you just dying to know the result, so, this is the type of series that you will finish watching in just 2-3 days. There are lots of suspects, some of them are innocent, some of them are not. We might not realized who is really guilty, even though we do, it still takes time to figure out why and how they did it. Also, when we thought some case is over, but it is not, there is always someone else behind the whole thing, or someone else related to the whole thing. I think the English title "Greed Mask" fits this series perfectly, good title, hmm.. I wonder who named that English title...
- How Come Factor
Wayne Lai VS Halina Tam
You will not have a single clue about what I am saying in this paragraph if you did not finish watching Greed Mask, or at least till the end of episode 19 (yuck, the end of episode 19 totally creeps me out). So, skip this part if you want to... Anyways, I guess what I am trying to say here is that, I don't like the true identity of Wayne, because it really creeps me out, and hate the way he speaks in episode 20. I agree that Wayne and Halina are important keys in the story, because without him or her, this series just feel different, because I loved the part where Wayne lost his memory, and tries to find out who he really is, this is a very special twist in the storyline, and just totally makes sense, and totally shocking. However, the makeover just totally unbelievable! I don't think there is some technology that is so advanced, and can make someone looks so different! I guess you will feel pity for Halina, who took revenge in a totally different way, and totally creepy way... this is scary...
Best Scenes
1. Roger and Annie together solving cases, they are pretty good partners... Both of them are really smart, and together they are making good chemistry, even though they are not lovers
2. Roger and his mother reunion, o my god, that tears coming out from Roger's eyes, makes me heart break!
3. When Wayne reveals the true identity to Roger, and how he planned the revenge. It is creepy, but it is a good scene when Wayne felt from the building, and Roger wants to save him, but it was too late... pretty emotional
4. All the creepy moments, which makes you want to watch what happen next, and making you feeling surprise about the way the series is made.... and the sequences of the storyline...
THE COMMENTS
- The Performances
All the true suspects are the most amazing factors in this series, because they all "wearing masks", you can not tell that they are the suspects because they pretend to be the nice ones. I think those people deliver very good performances, and making the audiences believe in them, then suspect them, then realized they are bad. Pretty much every single character is a suspect in this series, except Roger, his performances are very memorable... The only one screw up is Christine, as I told you, without her this series will be perfect, at least 95% perfect
- The Storyline
The storyline is almost perfect, I just think they need to work on the Wayne VS Halina part, that part is a little bit unbelievable, but I am not sure how they can rework that part if they have to. But, other than that, the story is really great, so interesting and everything just link each other perfectly.
- Worth Watching?
This series is very interesting, because you are trying to figure out who is the murder all the time, but even if you kind of know, you still have no idea why and how they did it, and also how they related to the entire story. You just need to keep watching and watching until you finally find out the result... Sometimes, the storyline really creeps you out, hmm.. don't watch it at night...
4 ) #謎情家族#很多年以前遇到神奇的一家人··有些話沒(méi)來(lái)得及說(shuō)
#謎情家族#很多年以前遇到神奇的一家人··有些話沒(méi)來(lái)得及說(shuō);第一案前女友的替身現(xiàn)女友找替身; 未來(lái)的女友有點(diǎn)神經(jīng),,,男主的命啊。第二事件 瘋狂的骨灰壇;這一家人的本性慢慢的凸顯出來(lái)了 當(dāng)年沒(méi)看透 現(xiàn)在再刷覺(jué)得這人物邏輯 真挺極品的。第三事件 是誰(shuí)殺了老爺;女二 女主 最后是姑父 主角這一家···人人都有問(wèn)題 如果我是男主 我想離家出走算了?!九鞯耐庑?,,,唉 國(guó)語(yǔ)版配音真的能給女主加分不少】其實(shí)這案子 一開始在表妹的部分 有一個(gè)大漏洞 問(wèn)如果表妹一個(gè)人殺人她的工作量和所需時(shí)間是多少 你這電視劇啊太難為觀眾了 讓觀眾相信表妹殺人?殺機(jī)都?jí)騿?。關(guān)于女主的部分 意料之外情理之中吧 她媽是大師的病人 所以是注定的 不過(guò)這電視劇的催眠他玄乎了 植入記憶 我承認(rèn)是可能的 但是條件苛刻是肯定的。這幾集 男主他姑姑 太看不清了。第四事件 詛咒事件 難言之隱的保姆 我們觀眾都看出來(lái)了,,。這一家子的人品也是沒(méi)誰(shuí)了。第五事件 三十年復(fù)仇的舅舅;雖然沒(méi)有當(dāng)年的驚訝 可是 女主舅舅這人物 我還是想不通 想拿別人的東西 可是30年你自己為什么 還是沒(méi)有錢,,唉 先想想自己吧。這電視劇的感情線 為什么不是表妹?表妹 說(shuō)到底想發(fā)展成男女之情 需要契機(jī)可是女主是不會(huì)給她這個(gè)時(shí)間 還有女主更大氣一些 不會(huì)想困男主這個(gè)浪子 。我突然想到個(gè)問(wèn)題 給賈寶玉選擇薛寶釵 可能是為了讓賈寶玉出去不要困在后宅。最后的事件 變性前女友的愛(ài);真是佩服 編劇的大膽故事 后期這前女友 沒(méi)有露餡真是不容易 我覺(jué)得女變男的難度 是不是太大了。后期感情線真是倉(cāng)促的可以 最后電視劇才想起來(lái) 人家女主和女二是表姐妹 所以說(shuō)這家人 真是奇怪 表姐妹沒(méi)有互動(dòng) 結(jié)局表妹來(lái)了個(gè)心靈感應(yīng),,,行吧錢都捐出去了 以后家里應(yīng)該能不折騰了吧,,應(yīng)該吧 反正覺(jué)得男女主他們是跑了。
5 ) 通過(guò)這部Get到安仔的顏
昨天看到第18集,一直耿耿于懷這部豆瓣打分不上八 本來(lái)打算給五星拉高得分的,今天看完之后...四星半好了∠( ? 」∠)_
好看是真好看 半星扣在真實(shí)性方面
—————//劇透分界//————
我還是挺吃男女主官配CP的...!就是這倆人不會(huì)好好溝通真要命,不過(guò)一部分原因也是人物關(guān)系太復(fù)雜導(dǎo)致吧~峰認(rèn)返云姐之后 他和彤彤真的好多事都瞞住珊呀,也不能怪她有點(diǎn)兒急躁 亂猜測(cè)吧。
佩佩出現(xiàn)之后峰就完全OOC了,居然說(shuō)出“雖然她是用計(jì)謀靠近我 我們還是有過(guò)感情”“結(jié)婚了也能繼續(xù)照顧你”這種屁話?!她騙你感情騙你錢、出軌你姑父、要?dú)⒛泸_保險(xiǎn)金都沒(méi)讓你放低她???
實(shí)在覺(jué)得彤彤和峰沒(méi)有CP感...當(dāng)妹妹二十多年看大的,怎么可能身世不同之后轉(zhuǎn)變成愛(ài)情嘛!彤彤就是性格內(nèi)向沒(méi)接觸太多人而已。但是想拆峰珊不是也耍了些手段?而且真搞不懂她干嘛弄一個(gè)佩佩聲音模擬器...查她 不用模擬她吧?后面也沒(méi)解釋~這模擬器任誰(shuí)見(jiàn)到都會(huì)覺(jué)得彤裝神弄鬼實(shí)錘
感覺(jué)全劇最好看的幾集是珊不斷發(fā)噩夢(mèng),然后發(fā)現(xiàn)夢(mèng)中意向正是別墅走廊、鏡中人竟然是自己,以及后面夢(mèng)到兇器位置并驗(yàn)證那段,雞皮疙瘩掉一地啊~~
最高超的暗線就是歐文偉一出現(xiàn)就懂化妝以及他引薦重要人物風(fēng)水先生??墒菤萘苏菥托邪樯顿M(fèi)大勁變性?而且恢復(fù)還挺快 還保留兩個(gè)聲線;最后兩集峰珊電話就是打不通 聯(lián)系不上;彤彤最后所謂的醒悟 峰珊的心有靈犀完全瞎說(shuō)(覺(jué)得他來(lái)過(guò) 沒(méi)走 大概率只是沙發(fā)還有他的體溫 什么心有靈犀啊扯)這些點(diǎn)讓我扣最終決定扣半星
佩佩也別搞什么癡情人設(shè)了 是男是女都是騙錢第一要?jiǎng)?wù)啊喂!女聲黎耀祥演的好好但也太容易笑場(chǎng)了哈哈哈哈哈哈哈又驚悚又想笑 尤其轉(zhuǎn)圈圈那里
以前總覺(jué)得安仔是搞笑擔(dān)當(dāng)那種,意外通過(guò)這部劇get到他的顏了呀?。∷v粵語(yǔ)有點(diǎn)點(diǎn)慢條斯理,萌~而且有些角度神態(tài)又好似張國(guó)榮...不愧是拿過(guò)幾次視帝的男人 愛(ài)了~
6 ) TVB最“奇葩”的編劇
看了很多TVB的劇,本劇“謎情家族”設(shè)置的懸念環(huán)環(huán)相扣,兇手反轉(zhuǎn)再反轉(zhuǎn)
①三十年前三結(jié)拜兄弟誰(shuí)殺了李杰
②高BOSS死于誰(shuí)手(自閉女?心理男?司徒)真兇最后露出,下巴掉下來(lái)!
③佩變偉,女變性成男,顛覆三觀,猜不透
總的來(lái)說(shuō)這部劇編的很好,節(jié)奏快,TVB最佳懸疑片,非常值得一看,五星推薦!
7 ) 劇情迷離奇葩,卻合乎情理
《謎情家族》算是TVB懸疑破案劇里的另類的,一般的懸疑破案劇由多個(gè)不同案件組成,每個(gè)案件會(huì)出現(xiàn)新角色,新角色與新案件有關(guān)。新角色一出現(xiàn),觀眾把他們與新案件自動(dòng)腦補(bǔ),會(huì)讓新案件多多少少失去原始神秘懸疑性。
但《謎情家族》不一樣,20集都在講述同一個(gè)故事和同一幫人,整個(gè)故事由幾個(gè)案件組成,牽涉的都是同一幫人,要說(shuō)新加入的“新角色”那只有黎耀祥了,但其實(shí)看到最后,ta也是原來(lái)的那幫人??础吨i情家族》讓我有一種濃厚的懸疑感,根本不知道編劇下一步想要表達(dá)什么,只知道每一個(gè)細(xì)節(jié)都是鋪墊。
比如說(shuō)樂(lè)佩佩的“林敏上身”和云姐的“詛咒案件”,編劇故意把事情描述得與玄學(xué)非常接近,企圖用鬼神之說(shuō)迷惑嚇唬觀眾,我?guī)缀跻脖贿@兩個(gè)案件嚇到,但越是科學(xué)無(wú)法解釋的事情,越證明這是人為之作,都是刻意精心鋪下的陷阱。
高卓文案件可謂貫穿整個(gè)大半部劇,只有高卓文一位被害人,牽涉的嫌疑人都在同一幫人里,卻讓人摸不著頭腦,連讓觀眾懷疑的對(duì)象都找不到。原以為塵埃落定的破案,之后被完全推翻,牽涉出另一個(gè)故事版本,然后掀出一層又一層的幕后黑手,這種神乎回轉(zhuǎn)、一環(huán)扣一環(huán)的劇情是其他TVB懸疑破案里所不具備的。
黎耀祥一案,編劇對(duì)ta的可謂各種鋪墊,讓觀眾各種猜不到。從一開始出場(chǎng)的人畜無(wú)害,到中間的失憶掀出背景成迷,到最后變性黑化,每一幕都撲朔迷離。ta失憶后,在ta家找不到過(guò)去,我還曾經(jīng)懷疑過(guò)ta是外星人,變成科幻劇了。黎耀祥的演技真是視帝級(jí)別的,一出場(chǎng)就覺(jué)得是個(gè)同性戀,因?yàn)槠缘囊轮虬绾蛪旱偷臏厝崧暰€,盡管到最后知道ta不是同性戀,但衣著打扮和聲音都是為揭開ta身份之謎作鋪墊的,這種自然不矯作的演技真的很贊。后來(lái),推薦司徒珊找崔志破解夢(mèng)境、協(xié)助司徒珊揭穿舅舅真面目,這些行為讓觀眾以為ta是真心幫助朋友的,而這一切都只是ta計(jì)劃中的一部分,讓所有人都不知不覺(jué)陷入ta鋪下的陷阱。
這部劇美中不足的是,一開始樂(lè)佩佩只是一個(gè)得不到高峰而受人擺布的傻女人,但變性后變得心思縝密,布局精密,邏輯思維滿分。
太好看了,但是我還是覺(jué)得高峰和彤彤最配,剛開始我以為男主最聰明,后來(lái)發(fā)現(xiàn)司徒柏年最聰明,最后發(fā)現(xiàn)最聰明的是佩佩,前面男主查到的案子全部都是他們一手安排的,最后佩佩本來(lái)什么都得到了,為了男主居然都放棄了,可是他最開始是為了錢想殺高峰的啊,郭晉安演技不錯(cuò)就是那個(gè)發(fā)型太丑了,黎耀祥演技太好了,最后兩集演的太好太好了,就是佩佩的樣子
單論劇集質(zhì)量,絕對(duì)是滄海遺珠,TVB的上乘之作。一個(gè)主線大案串起若干支案,環(huán)環(huán)相扣,迷霧重重,很難猜到劇情的走向,而且案件首尾閉環(huán)設(shè)計(jì)太牛逼了!唯一不滿的是,高峰明明是和表妹周依彤比較配啊……伍詠薇扮演的司徒珊,造型顏值,恕我接受無(wú)能,不是對(duì)伍詠薇有偏見(jiàn),真的老氣加奇葩。。。私以為,司徒珊這個(gè)角色,當(dāng)年找張可頤或者袁潔瑩來(lái)飾演,該有多好啊~
tvb歷年所有的懸疑劇里,這一部都可以稱為上乘之作吧。環(huán)環(huán)相套的線索現(xiàn)在看起來(lái)和當(dāng)年一樣過(guò)癮。如果我說(shuō)“伍詠薇”是這部劇里的瑕疵不知道有人反對(duì)嗎?不知道是不是角色定位的問(wèn)題,還是說(shuō)當(dāng)年的表演風(fēng)格就是這么浮夸,看起來(lái)真心讓人覺(jué)得很不舒服,如果換一個(gè)年輕一點(diǎn)的演員應(yīng)該會(huì)更好。
按照正常的邏輯本劇的主線根本就應(yīng)該是峰和珊的斗法,哪怕最后化敵為友。對(duì)于峰來(lái)說(shuō),珊明明是擺出偽善姿態(tài)不停地?cái)嚲?,觀眾都很難相信她沒(méi)壞心,人家男主卻能做到如此的大愛(ài)無(wú)疆,尤其是對(duì)比其對(duì)自己老媽的態(tài)度,我勒個(gè)去
扣一星是因?yàn)榇蠹业那楦邪l(fā)展都好怪,家族親情不是這么簡(jiǎn)單就可以放下的,男女主也不搭。不過(guò)這都細(xì)枝末節(jié),這部懸疑劇,一個(gè)大案貫穿始終,前后搞出6位嫌犯,料太足了,還有細(xì)密綿長(zhǎng)的伏線,最后還有雖然不大合理但驚奇度突破天際的神展開,非常好的作品,不虧是野澤尚!
故事整體挺不錯(cuò)的,TRICK也算是相當(dāng)大膽了,總體環(huán)環(huán)相扣,非常抓人。就是伍詠薇這個(gè)造型實(shí)在是……性格又太捉急,比文頌嫻差遠(yuǎn)了啊男主眼瞎差評(píng)減一星!
在我看過(guò)的港劇裡面,這一部絕對(duì)算得上驚喜的了。雖然破案的橋比較老套,但劇情反轉(zhuǎn),人物關(guān)係實(shí)在是太精彩了。感情戲也不會(huì)覺(jué)得油膩,相反峰同珊這對(duì)讓人覺(jué)得非常舒服。安仔真的好暖、好靚、好可愛(ài),演技亦都是大家認(rèn)可的。劇情雖然複雜,但不會(huì)讓人摸不著頭腦,非常好的一部劇。又激起我對(duì)安仔的愛(ài)啦
其實(shí)現(xiàn)在想起來(lái),是黎耀祥最出彩
太牛逼了!不看到最后根本不知道到底是怎么一回事,所有的案子串在一起,厲害!但是我從頭到尾一直討厭女主啊,我喜歡彤彤啊,我站定表哥表妹cp
玩法有趣,但!伍詠薇最糟糕的一次演技扣顆星,女主人設(shè)雞肋又毫無(wú)亮點(diǎn)還要跟男主硬湊cp再扣顆星。文頌嫻無(wú)論從演技還是人設(shè)這次都碾軋,機(jī)場(chǎng)對(duì)視那句“我相信你會(huì)為我選條正確的路”,以及最后藍(lán)色的水光和彩色的魚映著她閃著光的臉頰,從袒露心聲到“你不相信我”,最喜歡的兩段。黎耀祥贊贊的。
男主很帥,女主好老,以至于看到他們的戲碼就會(huì)出戲。。。女配很靚,勾的我又想去看談判專家和錦繡良緣了。劇情的層層反轉(zhuǎn)還算有點(diǎn)意思,雖然最后一幕有猜到,但看到畫面還是別扭死了。劇里好多鏡頭加上配樂(lè)看的毛骨悚然,如果小時(shí)候看的話,絕對(duì)是又一部留下童年陰影的劇。
一個(gè)案件貫穿始終,太強(qiáng)了。也是冬天在學(xué)??吹母蹌。瑴嘏剿?。
我覺(jué)得這是TVB看到目前最有連貫性最好的推理劇 越來(lái)越精彩 狼人裝村民 一個(gè)一個(gè)被揪出來(lái) 最后最大的狼王被揪出來(lái)了 視帝最后兩集演技炸裂了簡(jiǎn)直
司徒珊真是敗筆 第一次因?yàn)榕鞒蠖械嚼毖劬? 真的丑到暈厥 案子設(shè)計(jì)的可以 就是女主真心讓我想快進(jìn)
3星半 即便滿屏都稱贊著“一個(gè)大案貫穿始終”,但我始終覺(jué)得這才是本劇最遺憾的。毫無(wú)疑問(wèn)這個(gè)想法確實(shí)很贊,甚至對(duì)常年不注重劇集后期質(zhì)量的港劇而言,肯定會(huì)是本劇在比較上的一大優(yōu)點(diǎn)。事實(shí)上,為了將各個(gè)案件捆綁一起,編劇是下了功夫的,雖然很多地方我還是覺(jué)得蠻扯的,但中間盧海鵬被殺時(shí),情節(jié)的撰寫讓人意外,各種人物云疑四起,一番推論蓋一方推理,人性的漩渦、連續(xù)的反轉(zhuǎn)與真相,都讓人覺(jué)得即便前期劇情俗套、節(jié)奏懶散,但它仍有潛力成為TVB在某個(gè)領(lǐng)域的代表作??上ЫY(jié)局之后毛病掩都掩不上:前期急著進(jìn)入、后期擠著退出,只剩中間一點(diǎn)位置讓它展示沒(méi)能持續(xù)多久的精彩(黎耀祥那條線說(shuō)什么就是什么,實(shí)在欠缺說(shuō)服力)。而看著被迫粗糙對(duì)待的開頭與結(jié)尾,我知道這不是制作組的問(wèn)題,而是TVB讓人無(wú)語(yǔ)的機(jī)制老毛病了。另外女主太八婆,還是表妹好
很討厭這里面的伍姑娘。。。哎。。這里面郭晉安為嘛不能和文頌嫻好呢
本來(lái)以為是獨(dú)立案件劇結(jié)果非常巧妙地串聯(lián)成多年前真相的還原,穿插豪門恩怨和感情線。驚悚懸疑效果奇好,遠(yuǎn)超法證和日常警匪探案片。從小留下了深刻的心理陰影,還對(duì)催眠留下了神乎其神的印象。加星給編劇和本格推理。就是本劇郭晉安和伍詠薇實(shí)在顏值和演技都略一般了。
我醒哥。。。前面的懸疑抖很好看 就是結(jié)局太。。我醒哥那么man怎么可能是變性手術(shù)來(lái)的!
小時(shí)候在家看過(guò)片段,念念不忘,正好宿舍電視上有,就再看一遍,剛開始有些劇情還覺(jué)得熟悉,覺(jué)得挺一般的,越往后看才發(fā)現(xiàn)環(huán)環(huán)相扣,而且前面留了很多線索,拋去服裝發(fā)型和畫質(zhì),劇情真的很精彩了,現(xiàn)在拍的片子都沒(méi)這么好看。哦對(duì)了,本以為美劇的片尾曲會(huì)很多變,看到后幾集才發(fā)現(xiàn)原來(lái)這個(gè)劇的片尾曲也是根據(jù)劇情而變的,真是666
伍詠薇太顯老,跟娃娃臉的郭晉安配對(duì)實(shí)在違和。整體一個(gè)大案件貫穿始終,一環(huán)扣一環(huán),懸疑味道很濃,結(jié)尾最厲害,但著實(shí)有點(diǎn)過(guò)。